What is the Sound of One Hand Clapping?

Monday, April 13, 2009

You may have heard the famous zen riddle (properly known as a Kōan) that goes as follows:

 

What is the Sound of the Single Hand? When you clap together both hands a sharp sound is heard; when you raise the one hand there is neither sound nor smell. [...I]s it the essentials of what Yamamba describes in these words: “The echo of the completely empty valley bears tidings heard from the soundless sound?” This is something that can by no means be heard with the ear.

…or more commonly, the sound of one hand clapping.

 

Surely there is an answer, though. How can we find the amount of sound that one hand clapping produces?

Well, maybe we could ask Yahoo Answers.

…Or maybe not.

 

Unfortunately for the zen riddlers out there, the actual answer to the secret of the sound that is one hand clapping is not very mysterious. While you first have to find the sound of two hands clapping, which would require a very large sample size and a lot of averaging, there are several solutions, ranging from obvious to unobvious (which, according to the Firefox Dictionary Add-on, is not a word).

The Zen Riddler

 

Here are three solutions you can try to become a true grasshopper:

Resort to the Obvious

Even when you clap your hand against nothing — clapping with just one hand — you are producing some sound.

Your hand is compressing the air which will create soundwaves. Although it will sound a boring air woosh sound that is barely audible, this is — literally — the sound of one hand clapping. Take it or leave it.

Use Division

While not very sophisticated, you can simply record the sound of clapping your hands and then find the average volume of your clapping. Then, divide that volume by two. While not quite an answer as it is a work around, that’s the sound of one hand clapping, right? Buddah wouldn’t be proud, but it gets the job done.

Think about it as a Deaf Person

If you were deaf, you wouldn’t hear the sound of two hands clapping. You wouldn’t hear the sound of one hand clapping either. However, you would perceive the motion of one hand moving side-to-side idiotically as similar to that of half an applause.

So one would perceive it to be half as loud.

Clap Against a Non-Hand Object

While the Straight Dope refers to the sound of one hand clapping as the sound of “slapping someone in the face”. Presumably, you could simulate a “one handed clap” by clapping against any object other than your other hand.

Slapping: Now an answer to a Zen Riddle

 

Be Sociable, Share!

 

Liked this Essay?

5 Comments (RSS)

Read them below and add one yourself.

  1. Jeff says:

    I can make a sound similar to applause by whacking my fingers against the base of my palm. One hand clapping.

  2. Peter says:

    @Jeff: That actually works…

  3. Davo says:

    This is stupid. One hand CANNOT clap. It can do a lot of things, but it cannot clap….hence the expression “you are as much use as a one armed man in a clapping contest”!!! The dictionary definition of a clap is striking your hands (note plural haha) together. So there!!!

  4. Mahalaxmi says:

    This Koan has deep meaning…it is not an amusing statement…they are words from Zen monks. Please find the meaning from http://mahalaxmitr.blogspot.com/2009/07/sound-of-one-hand.html

  5. Mahalaxmi says:

    You cannot produce sound from one hand. Which means, what is left without sound is silence. The thoughtless mind in called silent mind. The WISDOM (Gnan in Hindi) or TRUTH (Sathya is Hindi)can be realized though the silent mind. Silence is the powerful language though which Wisdom/Truth can be explained/realized. Zen monks insists to make your mind a thoughtless one as through this silence they can teach what zen is, to their disciple. You call a ‘sound’ when you are able to listen to something. If that is so, if you are able to listen to silence (soundlessness) then you can call the silence as soundless sound. ‘Listen to the Silence’ is what been thought to Toyo.

    The below link explains this content and you can also find lot of other koan’s interpretations in my blog
    http://think-on-spirituals.blogspot.com/2009/07/sound-of-one-hand.html

Leave a Reply

Comment HTML: You can use HTML in comments. I reccomend <blockquote>Quote</blockquote> for quoting what others have said. <b>Text</b> is for bold, <i>Text</i> is for italic, and <a href="url">text</a> is for making links.